TELNET behavior poll results

Lee Chastain <lee@huachuca-jitcosi.army.mil> Thu, 01 December 1994 15:41 UTC

Received: from ietf.nri.reston.va.us by IETF.CNRI.Reston.VA.US id aa04507; 1 Dec 94 10:41 EST
Received: from CNRI.Reston.VA.US by IETF.CNRI.Reston.VA.US id aa04503; 1 Dec 94 10:41 EST
Received: from timbuk.cray.com by CNRI.Reston.VA.US id aa08039; 1 Dec 94 10:41 EST
Received: from sdiv.cray.com (daemon@ironwood.cray.com [128.162.21.36]) by timbuk.cray.com (8.6.9/8.6.9M) with SMTP id JAA08955; Thu, 1 Dec 1994 09:31:17 -0600
Received: by sdiv.cray.com (5.0/CRI-5.15.b.orgabbr Sdiv) id AA08108; Thu, 1 Dec 1994 09:31:12 -0600
Received: from timbuk.cray.com by sdiv.cray.com (5.0/CRI-5.15.b.orgabbr Sdiv) id AA08092; Thu, 1 Dec 1994 09:31:10 -0600
Received: from huachuca-jitcosi.army.mil (HUACHUCA-JITCOSI.ARMY.MIL [138.27.7.2]) by timbuk.cray.com (8.6.9/8.6.9M) with SMTP id JAA08900 for <telnet-ietf@cray.com>; Thu, 1 Dec 1994 09:30:54 -0600
Received: by huachuca-jitcosi.army.mil (4.1/SMI-4.1) id AA01740; Thu, 1 Dec 94 08:27:53 MST
Date: Thu, 1 Dec 94 08:27:53 MST
Sender: ietf-archive-request@IETF.CNRI.Reston.VA.US
From: Lee Chastain <lee@huachuca-jitcosi.army.mil>
Message-Id: <9412011527.AA01740@huachuca-jitcosi.army.mil>
To: telnet-ietf@cray.com
Subject: TELNET behavior poll results
Cc: iptp@huachuca-jitcosi.army.mil
Content-Length: 1387

Below are the results of my poll, as promised.  Our validation of the 
tester has shown it to be so bad that it just can't be used at all, and
we're sending it back to the drawing board.  One of the recommendations
will be that they use the proper well-known ports when testing FTP, 
SMTP, and TELNET.



The question boils down to this:  Is a TELNET user only a proper implementation
of TELNET when the server port is 23?         ^^^^

The consequences are as follows:

1.  No - TELNET is TELNET regardless of the server port :
    Then any implementation which defaults to LF as a newline (such as
    unix-based hosts) is not conformant to the TELNET standard.
    (Possible interoperability problems).

2.  Yes - TELNET is only TELNET when the server port is 23:
    Not only did the tester send the wrong character(s), but its testing
    methodology is seriously flawed; the use of the non-standard port
    means that it is not truly testing TELNET, whether it had sent the
    correct newline code or not.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Poll Results:

Preference	Who

1		philipp@res.enst.fr Thu Nov 17 10:34:16 1994
?		billw@cisco.com Thu Nov 17 17:05:21 1994
2		tytso@MIT.EDU Fri Nov 18 11:40:26 1994
1		braden@ISI.EDU Fri Nov 18 13:10:53 1994
1		tytso@MIT.EDU Fri Nov 18 13:18:30 1994


Thanks for your comments,
Lee Chastain.