Re: [TLS] Meeting minuts posted

Peter Sylvester <Peter.Sylvester@edelweb.fr> writes:

> Two procedural things:
>
> - Could the minutes have some indication about how many persons were
> present?

I don't remember anyone counting, but I would say arund 50.

> - The minutes say:
> "A show of hands indicated that while a number of people are
> interested in this item, only two were interested enough to agree to
> review the document and comment. Thus, this item will continue as an
> individual item."
>
> It is unacceptable to make decision only based on the presence of
> people in a meeting.
> According my understanding of working groups, the tls  mailing list
> are used to prepare
> such decisions.

My general practice is to post the minutes (that's been done)
and if people object to a decision that was made in the meeting,
then they can speak up at that point and we'll have a discussion.
I generally only explicitly ask for discussion on the list (as
with the TLS 1.2 issue) when the decision seems controversial.

In this particular case, there hadn't been much interest on
the list and since there wasn't much interest in the meeting,
so I didn't think *not* taking this work on would be particularly
controversial. Do you want to argue that the group should work
on this?

-Ekr

_______________________________________________
TLS mailing list
TLS@lists.ietf.org
https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/tls