[dmarc-ietf] Re: Review of draft-ietf-dmarc-arc-to-historic

"Murray S. Kucherawy" <superuser@gmail.com> Wed, 01 July 2026 19:33 UTC

Return-Path: <superuser@gmail.com>
X-Original-To: dmarc@mail2.ietf.org
Delivered-To: dmarc@mail2.ietf.org
Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by mail2.ietf.org (Postfix) with ESMTP id 373B910BC9EEA for <dmarc@mail2.ietf.org>; Wed, 1 Jul 2026 12:33:15 -0700 (PDT)
DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/simple; d=ietf.org; s=ietf1; t=1782934395; bh=nYlRunkZOTaGBjJfIDw/Rj9Uerm7ctwDls3uIW8U1J8=; h=References:In-Reply-To:From:Date:Subject:To:Cc; b=QZdsR5lcmmjLDsTWzBE4blXjZ1jvFnG/TsrqJDXwdsEGd1Aju67buA8uFL2+rroEF ZC3Oj30h9F2/fNh4IoCe+cRIEJ1FPDO91KusU4YUy9M1qbb4ow3a01YoJYaAhyouOz Pn7PqkPH48I8l3/UiKNwrLxVc8dtJNOl5yTZTz24=
X-Virus-Scanned: amavisd-new at ietf.org
X-Spam-Flag: NO
X-Spam-Score: -2.088
X-Spam-Level:
X-Spam-Status: No, score=-2.088 tagged_above=-999 required=5 tests=[BAYES_00=-1.9, DKIM_SIGNED=0.1, DKIM_VALID=-0.1, DKIM_VALID_AU=-0.1, DKIM_VALID_EF=-0.1, FREEMAIL_FROM=0.001, HTML_MESSAGE=0.001, RCVD_IN_DNSWL_NONE=-0.0001, SPF_HELO_NONE=0.001, SPF_PASS=-0.001, T_KAM_HTML_FONT_INVALID=0.01] autolearn=ham autolearn_force=no
Authentication-Results: mail2.ietf.org (amavisd-new); dkim=pass (2048-bit key) header.d=gmail.com
Received: from mail2.ietf.org ([166.84.6.31]) by localhost (mail2.ietf.org [127.0.0.1]) (amavisd-new, port 10024) with ESMTP id z2i5B8-6CmSS for <dmarc@mail2.ietf.org>; Wed, 1 Jul 2026 12:33:14 -0700 (PDT)
Received: from mail-lf1-x136.google.com (mail-lf1-x136.google.com [IPv6:2a00:1450:4864:20::136]) (using TLSv1.3 with cipher TLS_AES_128_GCM_SHA256 (128/128 bits) key-exchange X25519 server-signature ECDSA (P-256) server-digest SHA256) (No client certificate requested) by mail2.ietf.org (Postfix) with ESMTPS id 7782310BC9EE3 for <dmarc@ietf.org>; Wed, 1 Jul 2026 12:33:14 -0700 (PDT)
Received: by mail-lf1-x136.google.com with SMTP id 2adb3069b0e04-5aec139da7eso1148863e87.1 for <dmarc@ietf.org>; Wed, 01 Jul 2026 12:33:14 -0700 (PDT)
ARC-Seal: i=1; a=rsa-sha256; t=1782934393; cv=none; d=google.com; s=arc-20260327; b=SrCVm0KweBNDtxaQfiI2wRArKMSLtwrn2vJG0hQWkQMMDLeA4i5Bppajfa2aJG0zZw V1t8WU/7nxFD3Ds/ckgSkvBb4XY++OuZWXdw5mb5VSjP+LFF0z1PzhnW4CRGYBeTYp3j 0Cmx6xKWN9X4d5rZGzvwwBq1rAJvagjvWuLwaydye8lRRD6sfyiRa2WFzNq09QPp/gy2 1STC0LJXft/yraC1RZVcfW/zF2abejQU2Pke7YnA5/B3yM7W2LBaTSubhjXUDIIKthP9 qzyX0hpDrfQYk0lRQJiIW2+empdXJ94wBqXn95vchu4GLCinTD2rPsL0aFOJY2dN7OAi Q8Hg==
ARC-Message-Signature: i=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=google.com; s=arc-20260327; h=cc:to:subject:message-id:date:from:in-reply-to:references :mime-version:dkim-signature; bh=QnhekOYPEN+7i2Mp18cOpZfTFF/5JaPhfkRV04fFrsw=; fh=FUQHgZrvHDwFfIenxyRaouDoMZ4J6B9nxY7zFHht6RU=; b=FMa5IuxjNSaAjpMw2gHBOAWHaP96hP1vJ44h2iCcm0vpLfSQ6faqEvlFAwmZXPpknm rsoQ0Ak2SkyQXJ+0UPvO0qEFaf+J/c+3CgpK3DkLc5lZ7APuoNeKFAE01WkcPz0VIhTi WwbNJHO5YEKNgOkL4ndP7zxB8AkKMfbMNtjckqPxtJ7tclDn/71H61wnvqzPynomwa+6 3MyklGwwUEo8vHlZS6hCcVILH4bW7DbK2YVXBbXkT/HLi+NJK4eoEYbirBkhyMQ3upMa WUMEStyLLGyLyd1cgzJJzyaBX98Y7+/5B37Lr+NepsW0MzEXg00sXLr8gDR9aP+oAoB+ Wk9w==; darn=ietf.org
ARC-Authentication-Results: i=1; mx.google.com; arc=none
DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=gmail.com; s=20251104; t=1782934393; x=1783539193; darn=ietf.org; h=cc:to:subject:message-id:date:from:in-reply-to:references :mime-version:from:to:cc:subject:date:message-id:reply-to; bh=QnhekOYPEN+7i2Mp18cOpZfTFF/5JaPhfkRV04fFrsw=; b=RcpcBRpb5xSc4h4WlCFvLtwn1Zi5C+5+O39j3jWTdn9mnKjOOVg2JNYX4Kh/p9JWCe 1bAVEzSF3bVWOPfp/QZbQxbrlnjWKHMMoeHJvrbIQQOxbek9qYYs1hrf5oRQ8Yt7FtDV E75Xmle43GyZeWL535b0k/bR0EpG4hDHQNfEZlEXyXm2XhXw+gj3IiZHhcklC64anYEo NUcfMJFC9mrWERrPpt7Ov85Y/O70xyhqQl8zwKiWk+iru/IvnZLqAhrWeDHOF+J8SL4/ wqUOitPXwMQs6qNtNUFcIBPywx3sQ+V98xji6sTIgW+4Lh9Juq3vkqjVMld/53sY8374 WSFA==
X-Google-DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=1e100.net; s=20251104; t=1782934393; x=1783539193; h=cc:to:subject:message-id:date:from:in-reply-to:references :mime-version:x-gm-gg:x-gm-message-state:from:to:cc:subject:date :message-id:reply-to; bh=QnhekOYPEN+7i2Mp18cOpZfTFF/5JaPhfkRV04fFrsw=; b=QU+N/ZYh0cKERk+dW4s7n5KimrV/M1aA9ru1tyPRWSUjm/eRJ3eDDS3KDnoIzj4snN rTY5QQ5mXzO1Ko6EZbTXmmkvtblBZvWZa/iCbfdpPTPZZq4/dfTvVzNON9/l3D6/MfEa cEX9wVtyf2Wk4y5lsyxHXDg4PVcRSq5t0ZWRegQMhXYFRK3PqJikTZ1lRFfFCgc2r/Ob pkyge3SV4WNMqA1Apr7eU6nJfgXLBp0Bnj9FRkai3lBTR2LH8HN1TmtaWcAnAkIy5op9 8bbnCBmPK2OLfgB8wSt15AKvZhIMvDCWqUNHmd0x8RCL704NcYHPIyyVaWl2qa6ELRuX zz+A==
X-Gm-Message-State: AOJu0YwBnbH/xHIwLHQ8XL0qbcUrMMiNsJoC+ShbT2/ezDxGUVvCwPSH 3AS/4mNDW49bnhLNxKaZYc+3vol3K4Z6SgUTjou57AW0j5FCSH0EIkb27UaPoxdS1NQ8jDbg+5k 6YtOWUZ6eqaDboB33LrsWFUlG9s+h9fo=
X-Gm-Gg: AfdE7cnScz0ozCR718k7Axyc03IYgYgTMeNt2+C9dEyVn6swd5bPkWQUzSRJVY/3Ea3 6XwkJ8HyWgFt1W1dGNY8x07L5BNRp/IFs0Mak16tusocmkX9rGiI2gRYkMdD1RsDk6kcbTh4urf HwIXndT/XmkQbc4L8qzTGEaPXhZd8u+OgFOE/VwP2MtzW/BoHDdlr6P9/s5zwYMxbvgumIAxdWR OcOcAhuUY+cOeeD3I+K1Gc2TzmrFRq+2LH7Y7T8wJS07eG3Wxqco9hbTxQNz4YclPIOPFpww7ag yzVTirI+lqFE9xcYvrBQ1D9AKmQVQn8qm4pwt6QYKw==
X-Received: by 2002:a05:6512:640f:b0:5ae:bd1f:c83a with SMTP id 2adb3069b0e04-5aec62dc52amr808074e87.9.1782934392968; Wed, 01 Jul 2026 12:33:12 -0700 (PDT)
MIME-Version: 1.0
References: <27205.4140.707940.589907@fireball.acr.fi>
In-Reply-To: <27205.4140.707940.589907@fireball.acr.fi>
From: "Murray S. Kucherawy" <superuser@gmail.com>
Date: Wed, 01 Jul 2026 12:33:01 -0700
X-Gm-Features: AVVi8CeC0O3VtIG6HUTZAjpdjsXS6ASOcuEYUUwcZZyOMqUj7bFzTuMEbouriDw
Message-ID: <CAL0qLwYRBCs8hg=EZ-dg1VXFgQA7q6+X5kpqWz_AkpgwSG3WmA@mail.gmail.com>
To: Tero Kivinen <kivinen@iki.fi>
Content-Type: multipart/alternative; boundary="000000000000269902065591c3d9"
Message-ID-Hash: 272QCOJAEUHMTRFA7OQ3UUSH4FA7FNPD
X-Message-ID-Hash: 272QCOJAEUHMTRFA7OQ3UUSH4FA7FNPD
X-MailFrom: superuser@gmail.com
X-Mailman-Rule-Misses: dmarc-mitigation; no-senders; approved; emergency; loop; banned-address; member-moderation; header-match-dmarc.ietf.org-0; nonmember-moderation; administrivia; implicit-dest; max-recipients; max-size; news-moderation; no-subject; digests; suspicious-header
CC: dmarc@ietf.org
X-Mailman-Version: 3.3.9rc6
Precedence: list
Subject: [dmarc-ietf] Re: Review of draft-ietf-dmarc-arc-to-historic
List-Id: "Domain-based Message Authentication, Reporting, and Compliance (DMARC)" <dmarc.ietf.org>
Archived-At: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/dmarc/_oivxYts9prNraMKXARCIua1gDU>
List-Archive: <https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/browse/dmarc>
List-Help: <mailto:dmarc-request@ietf.org?subject=help>
List-Owner: <mailto:dmarc-owner@ietf.org>
List-Post: <mailto:dmarc@ietf.org>
List-Subscribe: <mailto:dmarc-join@ietf.org>
List-Unsubscribe: <mailto:dmarc-leave@ietf.org>

On Wed, Jul 1, 2026 at 6:12 AM Tero Kivinen <kivinen@iki.fi> wrote:

> ----------------------------------------------------------------------
> 11.1.  Success Consideration
>
>    In an attempt to deliver legitimate messages that users desire, many
>    receivers use heuristic-based methods to identify messages that
>    arrive via indirect delivery paths.
>
>    ARC will be a success if the presence of Authenticated Received
>    Chains allows for improved decision making when processing legitimate
>    messages, specifically resulting in equal or better delivery rates
>    than achieved through the use of heuristic approaches.
> ----------------------------------------------------------------------
>
> I think it succeeded in that. Almost all emails I receive have been
> forwardered to me by some forwarders. I know those forwarders (iki.fi,
> netbsd.org, ietf.org mailing lists, some other mailing lists).
>
> Email forwarding does not happen without the user interaction, i.e. I
> myself set up all of those forwardings and specified that those
> domains should forward those emails to me.
>
> When I receive email in my final mailbox I can use the ARC records
> from iki.fi to see whether DKIM, SPF and/or DMARC succeeded when it
> got the email. I do trust iki.fi so much that I allow it to forwarded
> emails to me, thus I trust that iki.fi will do those checks properly.
>
> The only interesting thing for the Chain is those machines that I
> trust. I do not care if someone else forwarded email before iki.fi got
> it, as I do not trust those. I only care about ARC headers that I know
> I can trust.
>
> Meaning the ARC was success as the precense of the ARC-records allowes
> me for improved decision making when processing legitimate messages,
> and checking those signatures is much better than heuristics using
> Received headers or something like that.
>

I think we need to consider whether the success criteria were met
generally.  I would argue that an existence proof, while interesting, is
probably not sufficient to establish consensus that the experiment was
broadly successful.

Put another way: You say it's valuable, but as I understand it, operators
handling enormous mail volumes across the broadest cross-sections of the
Internet have found that it's not.  I'm not asserting that the big
operators' opinions should automatically win the day, but we must reconcile
that dissonance somehow.  And I've heard a lot more assertions that it
provides no incremental value than assertions supporting it.

Then next section of the section 11 of ARC RFC 8617 lists failure
> considerations:
>
> ----------------------------------------------------------------------
> 11.2.  Failure Considerations
>
>    ARC should function without introducing significant new vectors for
>    abuse (see Section 9).  If unforeseen vectors are enabled by ARC,
>    this protocol will be a failure.  Note that the weaknesses inherent
>    in the mail protocols ARC is built upon (such as DKIM replay attacks
>    and other known issues) are not new vectors that can be attributed to
>    this specification.
> ----------------------------------------------------------------------
>
> The draft does not list any significant new vectors for abuse caused
> by ARC, and I do not know any of such things, so I assume there are
> none.
>

Whatever you may think of ARC and the value it provides, we can't ignore
that adoption remains very low after seven years.  My interpretation is
that the community at large just doesn't see value here.  This is
presumably after plenty of experimentation at all levels, given the
availability of free implementations, not to mention genuine deployment and
data collection by large operators.

I would argue that a failure criterion, whether express or inferred, is a
lack of uptake.

I think the more interesting line of inquiry is why uptake didn't
happen.  Maybe
it was complexity, maybe it was a lack of endorsement by large mailbox
operators, maybe it made headers too ugly, maybe making the users take
extra manual steps is unacceptable, maybe a mix of those, maybe something
else.  Knowing that might also help improve the chances of something like
DKIM2 succeeding.

Section 11.3 then goes to Open questions, i.e., what we should have
> learned from the experiment, but this draft does not answer those
> either.
>

I think the intent there was "Assuming this succeeds, what have we learned
from it?"  We're answering a different question now.


> So the summary is the current draft does NOT at all use the original
> sucecss / failure criteria to check whether experiment failed.
>

I think those were technical criteria.  We had high hopes and weren't
anticipating such limited adoption at the time.

-MSK