[IPsec] #123: Proposal to remove the IANA tables from IKEv2bis

Paul Hoffman <paul.hoffman@vpnc.org> Tue, 24 November 2009 00:37 UTC

Mime-Version: 1.0
Message-Id: <p06240847c730db1c447f@[10.20.30.158]>
Date: Mon, 23 Nov 2009 16:37:22 -0800
To: IPsecme WG <ipsec@ietf.org>
From: Paul Hoffman <paul.hoffman@vpnc.org>
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii"
Subject: [IPsec] #123: Proposal to remove the IANA tables from IKEv2bis
Precedence: list

This has flummoxed a few reviewers. Tables such as those in section 3.3.2 are already out of date because things have been added since RFC 4306. I propose that we remove all these tables from IKEv2bis, and add notes pointing to the current IANA registries. I cannot see how doing this lookup will hurt developers: in fact, it forces them to actually look at the up-to-date tables. I can see how we might want to leave the tables in, but it really is confusing.

--Paul Hoffman, Director
--VPN Consortium

[IPsec] #123: Proposal to remove the IANA tables … Paul Hoffman
Re: [IPsec] #123: Proposal to remove the IANA tab… Dan McDonald
Re: [IPsec] #123: Proposal to remove the IANA tab… Paul Hoffman
Re: [IPsec] #123: Proposal to remove the IANA tab… Dan McDonald
Re: [IPsec] #123: Proposal to remove the IANA tab… Dan McDonald
Re: [IPsec] #123: Proposal to remove the IANA tab… Paul Hoffman
Re: [IPsec] #123: Proposal to remove the IANA tab… Steven Bellovin
Re: [IPsec] #123: Proposal to remove the IANA tab… Yaron Sheffer
Re: [IPsec] #123: Proposal to remove the IANA tab… Pasi.Eronen
[IPsec] #123: Proposal to remove the IANA tables … Tero Kivinen
Re: [IPsec] #123: Proposal to remove the IANA tab… Paul Hoffman
Re: [IPsec] #123: Proposal to remove the IANA tab… Yaron Sheffer
Re: [IPsec] #123: Proposal to remove the IANA tab… Tero Kivinen
Re: [IPsec] #123: Proposal to remove the IANA tab… Paul Hoffman
Re: [IPsec] #123: Proposal to remove the IANA tab… Dan McDonald
Re: [IPsec] #123: Proposal to remove the IANA tab… Tero Kivinen
Re: [IPsec] #123: Proposal to remove the IANA tab… Paul Hoffman
Re: [IPsec] #123: Proposal to remove the IANA tab… Yaron Sheffer
Re: [IPsec] #123: Proposal to remove the IANA tab… Paul Hoffman
Re: [IPsec] #123: Proposal to remove the IANA tab… Valery Smyslov
Re: [IPsec] #123: Proposal to remove the IANA tab… Tero Kivinen
Re: [IPsec] #123: Proposal to remove the IANA tab… Paul Hoffman
Re: [IPsec] #123: Proposal to remove the IANA tab… Valery Smyslov
Re: [IPsec] #123: Proposal to remove the IANA tab… Paul Hoffman
Re: [IPsec] #123: Proposal to remove the IANA tab… Valery Smyslov
Re: [IPsec] #123: Proposal to remove the IANA tab… Paul Hoffman
Re: [IPsec] #123: Proposal to remove the IANA tab… Valery Smyslov
Re: [IPsec] #123: Proposal to remove the IANA tab… Tero Kivinen
Re: [IPsec] #123: Proposal to remove the IANA tab… Tero Kivinen
Re: [IPsec] Diffie-Hellman group transform IDs IA… Tero Kivinen
Re: [IPsec] #123: Proposal to remove the IANA tab… David Wierbowski
Re: [IPsec] Diffie-Hellman group transform IDs IA… Paul Hoffman
Re: [IPsec] Diffie-Hellman group transform IDs IA… Dan Harkins
Re: [IPsec] Diffie-Hellman group transform IDs IA… Tero Kivinen
Re: [IPsec] Diffie-Hellman group transform IDs IA… Paul Hoffman
Re: [IPsec] #123: Proposal to remove the IANA tab… Pasi.Eronen