Re: [P2PSIP] WG Call for adoption: draft-peng-p2psip-snmp-04

[Marc Petit-Huguenin <[e-mail]>]

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA256

I read this draft and I am not sure that it is ready for adoption as working
group item.  The draft seems to be doing 2 different things, 1) defining a MIB
for RELOAD and 2) using RELOAD to find the network manager.  For 1) I think
that the MIB as defined exposes only a very small set of data, and needs to be
extended.  For 2) I must say that I do not really understand the mechanism.

So this draft needs more work but I am not sure what WG adoption will get us.
 The energy in the WG is very low, and I think that this energy should be
better used WGLCing the existing WG drafts (as promised back in Quebec City),
and adopting drafts that are in better shape, like SHARE/DISCO.

Meanwhile I am willing to do a complete review of the document some time in
the future.

On 06/21/2012 06:06 AM, Carlos Jesús Bernardos Cano wrote:
> Hi,
> 
> In Paris, there was a hum asking the group for consensus to move towards 
> adopting the RELOAD SNMP draft as a working group item.
> 
> This email starts a 2-week consensus call on adopting
> 
> Title           : An SNMP Usage for RELOAD Author(s)       : YongLin Peng 
> Wei Wang ZhenWu Hao Yu Meng Filename        :
> draft-peng-p2psip-snmp-04.txt Pages           : 24 Date            :
> 2012-03-06
> 
> as a P2PSIP WG document. Please, read the current revision and state you 
> opinion either for or against adoption (and with reasoning why) in the 
> mailing list. The call for adoption ends 5th July 2012.
> 
> Brian & Carlos
> 

- -- 
Marc Petit-Huguenin
Email: [e-mail]
Blog: http://blog.marc.petit-huguenin.org
Profile: http://www.linkedin.com/in/petithug
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.4.12 (GNU/Linux)
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=x/pD
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----