[sidr] Poll: WG acceptance of draft-ymbk-rpki-grandparenting-02

[Alexey Melnikov <[e-mail]>]

Dear WG participants,

I would like to initiate 2+ weeks poll (ending on December 31st 2012) 
regarding acceptance of draft-ymbk-rpki-grandparenting-02.txt. Please 
reply to questions listed below. Send your replies to the mailing list 
or directly to WG chairs <[e-mail]>. I would like to 
avoid extended discussions of technical issues at this time, as I think 
people already made up their minds. However including pointers to 
earlier discussions is fine.

Alexey,
on behald of SIDR chairs.

----------------

1) Is the problem described/solved by draft-ymbk-rpki-grandparenting-02 
actually a problem that the WG needs to address? (Answer: yes or no. 
Additional information is welcomed, but I don't want people to repeat 
the whole discussion.)

2) If you answered "yes" to the question #1, please also answer the 
following question:

Is draft-ymbk-rpki-grandparenting-02 a reasonable starting point to 
become a WG document? Please choose one of the following:


a) Ready for Adoption (whether or not you have some specific issues with 
it. Also, this answer is unrelated to whether this should be a separate 
draft or a part of an existing draft).

b) Needs more work BEFORE Adoption

c) Should not be adopted. In particular this mean that you don't believe 
any amount of work on the proposed draft will address your issues. So 
any solution to this problem should be a new draft written from scratch.

d) Abstain/don't care


3) If you answered "a" or "b" above, please also answer the following 
question:

Does this need to be in a standalone draft, or can it be incorporated 
into another existing WG draft? When answering this question please only 
base your answer on technical reasons, in particular please leave the 
decision on who is going to edit the document (if it is standalone) to 
WG chairs.