Re: [Stox] review of core, chat, groupchat and presence

[Saúl Ibarra Corretgé <[e-mail]>]

Hi Philip,

Thanks for the feedback, I hope to look into these issues over the weekend and either make changes or come back with more questions :-)

> 
> groupchat:
>    2: at least in RFC 6120, jid stands for jabber id, not jabber
> 	identifier.
>    3.1: Room Nickname -> lowercase?
>    3.1: example f2: conversion->conversation?
>         table 1: thread<->call id
>    3.2: example f7: possibly use by= on the error element?
> 	xep 0045 has the conflicting resource in the from
>    3.4: "Occupant JID in another room" -- i don't think mediated
> 	invites work across different rooms.
>        example f1: hecate is benvolio? c&p error from 0045
>        example f2: contact [e-mail] has a wrong host?
>        reeived -> received
>        example f3 is not shown
>        below f4 there is a sip/2.0 200 ok on its own?
>    3.5: table 2: xmpp From/To -> from/to
>        ex f9: where is juliets own presence in msrp?
>        ex f11: where is juliets own presence with code 110?
>        ex f14: mapping <message id/> to Message-ID
>        	does msrp have a concept of room history?
>    3.6.2: do we have an equivalent disco feature for muc?
>    3.7: does xmpp still support the <status/> when in muc? In IRC this
> 	has caused PART spam
>    4.1: ex f5: lack of error until when? must wait until receiving 110
> 	status?
>    4.4: presence broadcast before ack? must buffer until receiving 110
> 	ack?
>    4.5.1: use message id instead of guessing?


--
Saúl Ibarra Corretgé
AG Projects