Re: [Uri-review] The registration request for “cstr” URI scheme

Dear Ted Hardie,
Thank you for your reply, we have already updated the security considerations and references including the cstr specification.The "cstr" scheme is specified as follows:

Scheme name: cstr

Status: Provisional

Applications/protocols that use this scheme name: 
A "cstr" URI is used to express an identifier that is for common science and technology resources.
Applications that use this scheme name provide services for the persistent identification, inluding citation, statistics and traceability of science and technology resources.

Security considerations:
   Unknown, use with care.

Contact: Wang Shu (wangshu@cnic.cn)

Change controllers:
  - Wang Shu (wangshu@cnic.cn)
  - Computer Network Information Center,Chinese Academy of Sciences 

References:
[1] https://www.cstr.cn/en/
[2] https://cstr.cn/doc/specification/

Please let me know if you have any questions about cstr.
Looking forward to your reply.
Best wishes.
Shu

wangshu@cnic.cn

发件人： Ted Hardie
发送时间： 2022-04-26 17:42
收件人： wangshu@cnic.cn
抄送： uri-review; liujia
主题： Re: [Uri-review] The registration request for “cstr” URI scheme
Dear Wang Shu,

Thank you for your message.  According to the guidelines in RFC 7595 for Provisional registrations:

For a 'provisional' registration, the following apply:
   o  The scheme name must meet the syntactic requirements of
      Section 3.8.
   o  There must not already be an entry with the same scheme name.  In
      the unfortunate case that there are multiple, different uses of
      the same scheme name, the Designated Expert can approve a request
      to modify an existing entry to note the separate use.
   o  Contact information identifying the person supplying the
      registration must be included.  Previously unregistered schemes
      discovered in use can be registered by third parties (even if not
      on behalf of those who created the scheme).  In this case, both
      the registering party and the scheme creator SHOULD be identified.
   o  If no permanent, citable specification for the scheme definition
      is included, credible reasons for not providing it SHOULD be
      given.
   o  The scheme definition SHOULD include clear security considerations
      (Section 3.7) or explain why a full security analysis is not
      available (e.g., in a third-party scheme registration).
   o  If the scheme definition does not meet the guidelines laid out in
      Section 3, the differences and reasons SHOULD be noted.

I did not see a security considerations section in your message, and it would be helpful if you could update to provide one.  Also, I assume the reference provided was intended to give a pointer to the full syntax of a CSTR.   I did not, however, find a link on that page to the syntax or a specification of CSTRs.  If you could update the link to point directly to that specification, that would also be appreciated.  If it would be simpler, you could also provide the syntax to CSTR directly in the registration.  Section 8 of RFC 7595 has an example of how to do that.

best regards,

Ted Hardie

On Tue, Apr 26, 2022 at 10:33 AM wangshu@cnic.cn <wangshu@cnic.cn> wrote:
Dear：
I am Wang Shu from Computer Network Information Center,Chinese Academy of Sciences, We plan to request a provisional URI scheme for cstr, that is an identifier for common science and technology resources, to provide identification service for science data repositories and data centers. The "cstr" scheme is specified as follows:

Scheme name: cstr

Status: Provisional

Applications/protocols that use this scheme name: 
A "cstr" URI is used to express an identifier that is for common science and technology resources.
Applications that use this scheme name provide services for the persistent identification, inluding citation, statistics and traceability of science and technology resources.

Contact: Wang Shu (wangshu@cnic.cn)

Change controllers:
  - Wang Shu (wangshu@cnic.cn)
  - Computer Network Information Center,Chinese Academy of Sciences 

References:
[1] https://www.cstr.cn/en/

Looking forward to your reply.
Best wishes.
Shu

wangshu@cnic.cn
_______________________________________________
Uri-review mailing list
Uri-review@ietf.org
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/uri-review