Re: [dtn-security] Newbie seeking some security related advice
Armando Caro <acaro@bbn.com> Thu, 28 May 2009 18:32 UTC
Received: from mx11.bbn.com (mx11.bbn.com [128.33.0.80]) by maillists.intel-research.net (8.13.8/8.13.8) with ESMTP id n4SIWCja012917 for <dtn-security@maillists.intel-research.net>; Thu, 28 May 2009 11:32:12 -0700
Received: from [128.89.254.152] (helo=dhcp192-1-118-109.bbn.com) by mx11.bbn.com with esmtp (Exim 4.60) (envelope-from <acaro@bbn.com>) id 1M9kLh-00051q-Dj; Thu, 28 May 2009 14:29:05 -0400
Message-ID: <4A1ED7F1.2040304@bbn.com>
Date: Thu, 28 May 2009 14:29:05 -0400
From: Armando Caro <acaro@bbn.com>
User-Agent: Thunderbird 2.0.0.21 (Macintosh/20090302)
MIME-Version: 1.0
To: "Ivancic, William D. (GRC-RHN0)" <william.d.ivancic@nasa.gov>
References: <89E48AE60E64EF4E8EB32B0B7EC74920A1B0F5@EVS-EC1-NODE2.surrey.ac.uk> <4A12195A.6000207@LeonixSolutions.com> <3A5AA67A8B120B48825BFFCF5443856137E0B06196@NDJSSCC03.ndc.nasa.gov> <4A1DD73F.50000@bbn.com> <4A1DF457.1060400@LeonixSolutions.com> <3A5AA67A8B120B48825BFFCF5443856137E0BCCDF0@NDJSSCC03.ndc.nasa.gov>
In-Reply-To: <3A5AA67A8B120B48825BFFCF5443856137E0BCCDF0@NDJSSCC03.ndc.nasa.gov>
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="ISO-8859-1"; format="flowed"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit
Cc: "dtn-security@maillists.intel-research.net" <dtn-security@maillists.intel-research.net>
Subject: Re: [dtn-security] Newbie seeking some security related advice
X-BeenThere: dtn-security@maillists.intel-research.net
X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.9
Precedence: list
List-Id: DTN Security Discussion <dtn-security.maillists.intel-research.net>
List-Unsubscribe: <http://maillists.intel-research.net/mailman/listinfo/dtn-security>, <mailto:dtn-security-request@maillists.intel-research.net?subject=unsubscribe>
List-Archive: <http://maillists.intel-research.net/pipermail/dtn-security>
List-Post: <mailto:dtn-security@maillists.intel-research.net>
List-Help: <mailto:dtn-security-request@maillists.intel-research.net?subject=help>
List-Subscribe: <http://maillists.intel-research.net/mailman/listinfo/dtn-security>, <mailto:dtn-security-request@maillists.intel-research.net?subject=subscribe>
X-List-Received-Date: Thu, 28 May 2009 18:32:13 -0000
Ivancic, William D. (GRC-RHN0) wrote: > ->Armando Caro wrote: > ->What about "transiently" disconnected nodes? Can we accept loss of > ->transmission for a fraction of a second? Or even a few seconds? > -> > > That is up to the acceptability of the end user. For example, I prefer the grainy ghost of analog TV to Digital TV with interrupted voice bits and pixilation during signal fades. > > ->If I stipulate a network that carries primarily voice traffic (albeit > ->as VoIP), then what does DTN bring me? I could argue that it adds a > ->degree of complexity that brings no gain. > > I would agree. > > ->I suppose that the gain is > ->that the network is distributed and has no central infrastructure > ->(although, to split hairs, that is an ah-hoc network, which not all DTN > ->need to be); I can see that that would be attractive to DARPA. > > A DTN can be an overlay on an Ad Hoc network or an overlay on a fixed fully connected network or an overlay on a predictive network like a deep space network or a combination. My personal view of a DTN to date is an application level store-and-forward gateway and/or potentially a secure content storage and distribution network. Until we get some type of scalable naming structure, I don't see this scaling very well. > I'm confused, because I don't remember writing the words above that you quoted me as saying. I did say the following paragraph: > ->> One important take-away from this work... the motivation of DTN is to > ->> support delay/disrupted scenarios and apps that can operate in that > ->> regime, but it is possible to implement a DTN stack that can also > ->deal with time-sensitive traffic. > One thing I see is that many non-technical or even technical, but uninformed/misinformed people think DTN is a magic box that you put in front of applications that require a connected network and it makes them work in a disconnected, store-and-forward, environment. I agree that there are many people who are uninformed about what exactly DTN is and how it works. > > I think we need to educate people that this is not the case. I agree. > However, I think that sometimes we don't in order to obtain/retain funding. It's always important to educate the customer funding a project, because otherwise the customer will have unrealistic expectations. I think (at least I would hope) that people involved in acquiring funding understand that it is critical to ensure that a customer maintains realistic expectations. Otherwise the end result will be a failure in the eyes of the customer, and that is detrimental to future funding prospects from that same customer. There is nothing dishonest about the claim that BBN's DTN stack is able to handle time-sensitive VoIP traffic. In Dec 2008, we demo'd this capability for small multihop wireless networks. The point we are trying to make in the WNaN program is that there should be a single network stack and it should include DTN functionality. The applications should specify whether or not their traffic should tolerate delays/disruptions. Then when disruptions occur, the "DTN functionality" is invoked only for the app traffic that is declared to be delay/disruption tolerant. Armando
- [dtn-security] Re(2): [dtn-interest] Bundle Secur… Peter Lovell
- Re: [dtn-security] [dtn-interest] Bundle Security… Hans Kruse
- [dtn-security] Bundle Security Protocol Implement… M.Bhutta
- Re: [dtn-security] Newbie seeking some security r… Armando Caro
- Re: [dtn-security] Newbie seeking some security r… Ivancic, William D. (GRC-RHN0)
- Re: [dtn-security] Newbie seeking some security r… Graham Keellings (Leonix Solutions Pte Ltd)
- Re: [dtn-security] Newbie seeking some security r… Jason Redi
- Re: [dtn-security] Newbie seeking some security r… Armando Caro
- Re: [dtn-security] Newbie seeking some security r… Kristian Erik Hermansen
- Re: [dtn-security] Newbie seeking some security r… Ivancic, William D. (GRC-RHN0)
- Re: [dtn-security] Newbie seeking some security r… Stephen Farrell
- Re: [dtn-security] Newbie seeking some security r… Graham Keellings (Leonix Solutions Pte Ltd)
- Re: [dtn-security] Newbie seeking some security r… Kristian Erik Hermansen
- [dtn-security] Newbie seeking some security relat… Graham Keellings (Leonix Solutions Pte Ltd)
- [dtn-security] Re(many): Is there a "secure" refe… Peter Lovell
- Re: [dtn-security] Re(2): Re(2): Is there a "secu… Graham Keellings (Leonix Solutions Pte Ltd)
- Re: [dtn-security] Is there a "secure" reference … Peter Lovell
- [dtn-security] Re(2): Re(2): Re(2): Is there a "s… Peter Lovell
- [dtn-security] Re(2): Re(2): Is there a "secure" … Peter Lovell
- Re: [dtn-security] Re(2): Is there a "secure" ref… Graham Keellings (Leonix Solutions Pte Ltd)
- [dtn-security] Re(2): Is there a "secure" referen… Peter Lovell
- Re: [dtn-security] Is there a "secure" reference … Graham Keellings (Leonix Solutions Pte Ltd)
- [dtn-security] Re(2): Is there a "secure" referen… Peter Lovell
- Re: [dtn-security] Is there a "secure" reference … Graham Keellings (Leonix Solutions Pte Ltd)
- [dtn-security] Is there a "secure" reference impl… Graham Keellings (Leonix Solutions Pte Ltd)
- [dtn-security] Re(2): Newbie seeking some securit… Peter Lovell
- Re: [dtn-security] Newbie seeking some security r… Jason Redi
- Re: [dtn-security] Newbie seeking some security r… Stephen Farrell
- Re: [dtn-security] Newbie seeking some security r… Ivancic, William D. (GRC-RHN0)
- Re: [dtn-security] Newbie seeking some security r… Graham Keellings (Leonix Solutions Pte Ltd)
- Re: [dtn-security] Encrypted IP headers Graham Keellings (Leonix Solutions Pte Ltd)
- [dtn-security] Re(2): Encrypted IP headers Peter Lovell
- Re: [dtn-security] Encrypted IP headers Graham Keellings (Leonix Solutions Pte Ltd)
- [dtn-security] Re(2): Re(2): How do you feel abou… Peter Lovell
- Re: [dtn-security] Re(2): How do you feel about B… Graham Keellings (Leonix Solutions Pte Ltd)
- Re: [dtn-security] Re(2): Re(2): Re(2): Is there … Ivancic, William D. (GRC-RHN0)
- [dtn-security] Re(2): Re(2): Re(2): Is there a "s… Peter Lovell
- [dtn-security] Re(2): How do you feel about Bonjo… Peter Lovell
- Re: [dtn-security] How do you feel about Bonjour/… Graham Keellings (Leonix Solutions Pte Ltd)
- Re: [dtn-security] How do you feel about Bonjour/… Graham Keellings (Leonix Solutions Pte Ltd)
- Re: [dtn-security] Re(2): Re(2): Is there a "secu… Graham Keellings (Leonix Solutions Pte Ltd)
- Re: [dtn-security] How do you feel about Bonjour/… Peter Lovell
- [dtn-security] How do you feel about Bonjour/Avah… Graham Keellings (Leonix Solutions Pte Ltd)