Re: [MMUSIC] BUNDLE goes UP: Do we need port zero for bundle-only m- lines?

[Adam Roach <[e-mail]>]

On 8/8/13 07:21, Hadriel Kaplan wrote:
> What I think should happen is the UAS should send an SDP answer using port=0 for those same m-lines

Why? You're proposing that we remove the mechanism for rejecting media 
streams. Consider the example I put up during the meeting: you have a 
regular audio m-line and a bundle-only video m-line. The other end wants 
to decline the video. You've just taken away the tool for doing so.

There'd better be a heck of an upside to removing this critical protocol 
mechanism. So far, the upside you've described is "Hadriel thinks it's 
not aesthetically pleasing," which doesn't seem to be a very practical 
consideration. Is there a technically compelling argument for your position?

/a