Re: [Ospf-wireless-design] Design Team slides for IETF 63

Henderson, Thomas R wrote:

>All,
>The design team is not meeting in Paris, due to lack of a quorum.  Acee
>Lindem agreed to present the attached slides at the OSPF and MANET WG
>meetings.  Any comments?
>  
>
 From my meta-feeling and observation of proposals/discussion frequency, 
methodology
used, I think you are at the point where you should open your results to 
a wider forum.

>Currently, we have two fairly mature proposals for how to do OSPF MANET
>extensions, and one public implementation of each.  As for next steps,
>you will see a statement in the charts that we have not yet achieved
>consensus.  Acee indicated his preference to let the design team run for
>one more cycle, possibly augmented by discussion on the regular MANET
>and OSPF WG lists.  Are there comments on this proposed approach?
>  
>
Again, I think you should release the software to a wider audience and 
let people run their
scenarios and provide you with results. This should give you  a good 
indication what the
consensus on the two proposals or a variation thereof should be beside 
purely technical
points that you seem have shaken out roughly and do seem to have a 
struggle merging
(again, from my understanding so far the two have different strengths 
depending
on the scenario assumed).  Then, IMHO you will be able to progress to 
spec-stage work.

    --- tony

_______________________________________________
Ospf-wireless-design mailing list
Ospf-wireless-design@lists.ietf.org
https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/ospf-wireless-design