What's your favorite MTU?
mogul (Jeffrey Mogul) Tue, 10 April 1990 02:17 UTC
Received: by acetes.pa.dec.com (5.54.5/4.7.34)
id AA04266; Mon, 9 Apr 90 19:17:38 PDT
From: mogul (Jeffrey Mogul)
Message-Id: <9004100217.AA04266@acetes.pa.dec.com>
Date: 9 Apr 1990 1817-PST (Monday)
To: mtudwg
Cc:
Subject: What's your favorite MTU?
After spending a week or so at it, I'm nearly done with a trial implementation of Steve Deering's DF-based scheme. Recall that he expects an "upgraded" router to send ICMP Dest. Unreachable/ Fragmentation needed and DF set (or DU/FNDS) messages with the currently "unused" field set to the maximum MTU it can forward on the given path. Meanwhile, if the router sending the DU/FNDS is NOT upgraded, it sends 0 in this field, so the sending host (i.e., the host receiving the ICMP) can at least know to crank down its path MTU estimate. Once I figured out that 4.xBSD-based routers all slightly mangle the Length field in the "Internet header of Original Datagram", I decided to base my estimate on the (conservatively corrected) value of this field. Clearly, though, the estimate has to be lower than the old IP Length, since that length was too long. My first approach was to simply cut the length by 25% on each trial; this, however, didn't seem to scale well. Suppose one has end-hosts on FDDI (MTU = 4478) networks and there is a SLIP link (MTU = 296) in between. 296/4478 = .066, and you have to raise .75 to the 10th power before the result is < .066. So, it would take 10 round-trip times before the sender got an estimated Path MTU low enough that segments would start making it to the far end. If I make the decrement more than 25%, then convergence is faster but it is likely to be even further from optimal when it does converge. So I was a little disappointed. A little research in the RFC archives, however, suggests that there are actually very few reasonable values for Path MTUs. I count about 9, although I could be missing some. I went through all the RFCs listed in RFC1130 as describing IP encapsulations, made a chart of the MTUs specified, and arranged them in declining order. Then I grouped similar values together, and picked a set of plateaus corresponding to the least element in each group. In most cases, the choice of groups is quite clear; I'm a little concerned about the plateaus I picked at smaller MTU sizes, but none of my values is more than 17% from optimal for its group. The new algorithm is to step down through the plateaus until you hit one which is lower than your previous attempted IP Length. In the FDDI-SLIP-FDDI scenario, this converges in 5 RTTs, not 10. FDDI-Ethernet-FDDI converges in two steps, to within 3% of optimal. The table at the end of this message shows my results (the figures in parentheses show how far from optimal the worst-case member of each group lies). I would appreciate it if people could correct any mistakes in this table, and tell me about data links (such as Amateur Packet Radio) that I've left out. Also, if I've included any data links that are completely obsolete, please let me know! -Jeff PMTU-plateau MTU Protocol Comments Specification 65535 IP Official Maximum MTU RFC 791 65535 IP-HC Hyperchannnel RFC 1044 65535 8166 IP-IEEE IEEE 802.4 RFC 1042 8166 4478 IP-FDDI FDDI RFC 1103 4478 2048? IP-WB Wideband Network RFC 907 2002 IP-IEEE IEEE 802.5 RFC 1042 2002 (2%) 1536 IP-EE Exp. Ethernet Nets RFC 895 1500 IP-E Ethernet Networks RFC 894 1492 IP-IEEE IEEE 802.3 RFC 1042 1492 (3%) 1006 IP-SLIP Serial Lines RFC 1055 1006 IP-ARPA ARPANET BBN 1822 1006 576 IP-X25 X.25 Networks RFC 877 544 Portal DEC IP Portal -------- 512 IP-NETBIOS NETBIOS RFC 1088 508 IP-IEEE IEEE 802/Source-Rt Bridge RFC 1042 508 IP-ARC ARCNET/extended RFC 1051 508 (13%) 296 IP-SLIP Serial Lines (Van Jacobson) RFC 1055 253 IP-ARC ARCNET RFC 1051 252 (17%) 68 IP Official minimum MTU RFC 791 Don't Know IP-DC DC Networks RFC 891
- What's your favorite MTU? Jeffrey Mogul
- Re: What's your favorite MTU? Art Berggreen
- Re: What's your favorite MTU? Jeffrey Mogul
- Re: What's your favorite MTU? Drew Daniel Perkins
- Re: What's your favorite MTU? Drew Daniel Perkins
- What's your favorite MTU? Fred Bohle acc_gnsc
- Re: What's your favorite MTU? Jeffrey Mogul
- Re: What's your favorite MTU? Drew Daniel Perkins