Re: [Multiformats] Multiformats Considered Harmful

[Melvin Carvalho <[e-mail]>]

pá 8. 9. 2023 v 9:50 odesílatel Robin Berjon <[e-mail]> napsal:

> On 07/09/2023 19:25, Melvin Carvalho wrote:
> > A way I often think of IPFS and Filecoin is similar to Apple's iPhone
> > and iOS: two creations from the same origin, meant to complement each
> > other. Just a perspective that might offer some clarity as we discuss
> > documentation and standardization avenues
>
> Unfortunately, that is even more inaccurate and misleading than your
> previous description. I'm not sure that I understand what you're trying
> to get at insisting on a point that is factually incorrect and seems
> irrelevant either way.
>
> Authoritatively, the IPFS Principles[0] define what is part of the IPFS
> stack. This doesn't include such things as Filecoin, CEPT2 Teletel
> Videotex, ponies, or warmer shades of the colour yellow. It wouldn't
> make a lot of sense, likeable as some of these may be.
>

Thank you for your insights. However, I'd like to highlight a couple of
statements from key figures in the community

- Orie Steele from the W3C Verifiable Credentials group mentioned, "A
community of folks working on multiformats... Filecoin, IPFS community...
multibase emerges from those communities."
- Juan Bennet, at a W3C workshop, stated, "Though not a blockchain itself,
IPFS is highly relevant to Blockchains. It is used by blockchains and
blockchain applications, and its subprotocols (libp2p, multihash, IPLD) can
be extremely useful for blockchain standardization. I am also the inventor
of the Filecoin protocol, which is a blockchain storage currency."

While I understand and respect the distinctions you're emphasizing, it's
evident from the aforementioned statements that there's a recognized
connection and relevance between IPFS, Filecoin, and blockchain-related
efforts. I believe this context is essential in our discussions, and it
would be beneficial for us to acknowledge these ties while also
understanding the unique characteristics of each project.
I trust this sheds light on the context I'm referencing. To ensure
productive discussions, I'd suggest we remain focused on the primary topics
and avoid reiterating points. Appreciate your understanding.


>
> [0] https://specs.ipfs.tech/architecture/principles/
>
> --
> Robin Berjon (he/him)
> Governance & Standards at Protocol Labs
> https://berjon.com/ - https://mastodon.social/@robin
>