Re: [DNSOP] Alternative Special-Use TLD problem statement draft

["Paul Hoffman" <[e-mail]>]

On 5 Apr 2016, at 16:35, Ted Lemon wrote:

> I wrote about six pages of comments on the recently-submitted 
> special-use TLD problem statement document.   However, ultimately I 
> concluded that it would be easier to just write what I thought the 
> problem statement should look like rather than try to suggest (and 
> then no doubt discuss one by one) a large set of changes that I think 
> it needs.
>
> So this weekend I spent quite a bit of time talking to various people 
> who I knew would have insight into the question, and the result is the 
> draft I just submitted.  Ralph Droms was instrumental in inspiring me 
> to write the document, and helped me out by doing an initial review.
>
> I've included the submission announcement below.   I realize that this 
> is a woefully late submission for discussion at IETF 95, since I 
> mostly wrote it yesterday, _at_ IETF 95.   However, I think it may 
> serve as a better starting point for the discussion than the current 
> problem statement draft, so if you have time to read it, I would 
> genuinely appreciate it if you could give it a look.

Clarifying question: are you formally requesting the WG to stop work on 
draft-adpkja-dnsop-special-names-problem and switch to this one? If not, 
what do think we should do about the two?

--Paul Hoffman