Re: [dhcwg] WGLC for draft-ietf-dhc-dhcpv4-over-dhcpv6-03 - Respond by Dec 9, 2013

[Sten Carlsen <[e-mail]>]

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1


On 03/12/13 12.54, Ole Troan wrote:
> Bernie,
>
>> I don't understand your points here. Your solution is not what RFC
7040 references either. And in fact the dhcpv4-over-dhcpv6 solution is
very close to the dhcpv4-over-ipv6 solution as in some of the models it
also only uses IPv6 packets.
>
> my point was that you've already put one alternative way of carrying
DHCPv4 out there. my question was if you should try to put that cat back
into the bag?
>
> in any case, let's not digress on RFC7040. that wasn't the point.
>
> it appears you think it is important that DHCPv4 uses "only IPv6
packets". that's what a tunnel does, why do you think DHCPv4 needs to
build its own transport?
A couple of questions comes to mind here (at least my mind):
- - Is the IPv4 island expected to be a real island all on it's own OR
is it an island connected via a tunnel to other islands of IPv4?
- - Will the DHCP4 server have IPv4 connectivity via the tunnel and
maybe more or will it be all IPv6, with only the DHCP4 communicating
over it's own protocol?
>
>
> cheers,
> Ole
>
>

- -- 
Best regards

Sten Carlsen

No improvements come from shouting:

       "MALE BOVINE MANURE!!!"
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG/MacGPG2 v2.0.18 (Darwin)
Comment: Using GnuPG with Thunderbird - http://www.enigmail.net/
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=mBol
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----