Re: [re-ECN] Conex charter - now in External Review

[ken carlberg <[e-mail]>]

On Apr 28, 2010, at 11:21 AM, John Leslie wrote:

>   In the past, Lars has asked other IESG members to put their concerns
> in writing. It is reasonable to assume Stewart is responding to such
> a request. Please recall, Stewart is a new IESG member, and may not be
> familiar with all the history we would like him to be -- i.e. let's
> cut him some slack, please.

I quite agree about cutting the fellow a lot of slack.  And I'll respectfully extend my apologies if my earlier response was considered too abrupt....its always hard to convey proper tone over email.

I deeply appreciate Stewart speaking up on the matter on the list.  And whether the proper response to the business oriented questions are "it doesn't matter" or "its out of scope" is possibly splitting hairs.  I just feel strongly that a measure of consistency approach taken by all.

as for the MPLS question, I thought that Bob Briscoe had responded to that question at the Anaheim meeting.  And if so, perhaps he could reiterate it on the list.

cheers,

-ken