Re: [apps-discuss] DMARC working group charter proposal

[Barry Leiba <[e-mail]>]

>> I strongly suggest changing that sentence so that it gives a more
>> workable characterization of what's out of scope.
>
> please suggest specific text that you feel would better do the job here.

I gave the parameters and thought you'd prefer to do the text.  But
I'm happy to propose some:

OLD
The working group will capture feedback about the existing DMARC
specification, and provide it for any future revision effort. However
discussion, debate and resolution of issues that target revision of
the specification are out of scope for this working group.
END

My first preference would be to remove that paragraph entirely; I
think the rest of the charter lays out the guidelines sufficiently.

If you really want to keep it, I think this will address my concerns:

NEW
The working group will capture feedback about possible extensions to
the DMARC specification, and provide it for any future effort.  Such
extensions and accommodation of additional use cases are out of scope
for this working group.
END

Barry