Re: AD Sponsorship of draft-moonesamy-recall-rev

[S Moonesamy <[e-mail]>]

Hi Stephen,
At 05:04 AM 25-05-2019, Stephen Farrell wrote:
>No specific briefing no. I'd say a bunch of IAB members are
>likely aware of the discussion.

Thanks for the input.

>Are you asking the IAB to collectively answer that question?

I'd say that an answer from an IAB member is good enough.

>IIUC the "IAB shepherd" thing happens when the IESG ask the
>IAB for someone to shepherd a BoF proposal and they've not
>asked us in this case that I recall. I don't think it'd be
>a good plan if the IAB decided to try muscle in to "shepherd"
>things that might or might not turn into a BoF without being
>asked by the IESG.

Thanks, Stephen.  That is useful to know.

>And FWIW, in this case, even if asked by the IESG, my starting
>position would be "no, this isn't something suited for an
>IAB shepherd as it's an IETF process related proposal" but
>others may have other opinions and I don't feel strongly about
>it so I could well be convinced otherwise if the IAB were
>asked by the IESG.

I appreciate that you shared your opinion openly.  It is not up to me 
to convince you to change it or ask you to take a strong position.

Regards,
S. Moonesamy