Re: [rrg] Why won't supporters of Loc/ID Separation (CEE) argue their case?

[Tony Li <[e-mail]>]

Hi Robin,

>> Also, we've been over (and over and over) the points here repeatedly.
> 
> Can you point to some messages or other documents where you or others
> argue that the delays, extra packets, extra complexity etc. I believe
> Loc/ID Separation forces on all hosts are either non-existent or a
> price worth paying for saving on the additional routing system
> complexity required by the only other obvious solution - Core-Edge
> Separation (ITRs, ETRs and tunneling)?

Again, I refuse to get into debates about mechanism trivialities.  If we
were going to have an architectural debate, then it should be about the
solution space.  Classes of solutions, not about the engineering details.
We've recently touched on this when we started tried to talk about groups of
proposals.

>> I'm happy to have a reasoned debate about
>> architectural issues, but I'm not about to have another yes-no-yes-no
>> argument and I'm not interested in debating mechanisms.
> 
> Are you interested in debating anything on the list?

Asked and answered.

Tony