Re: [rrg] FW: I-D Action:draft-irtf-rrg-recommendation-06.txt

[Tony Li <[e-mail]>]

Hi Robin,

> Is there any reason for the apparently un-ordered sequence of the
> proposals?  They are not alphabetically arranged, or grouped in any way.


The are arranged in the order that I processed them.  This is roughly the
order that they appeared in my mailbox.

 
> On 4 March I sent you a revised critique for Compact Routing, cut to
> 500 words by moving some non-critical parts of it to Hannu's "rebuttal".
> Hannu replied to us he was happy with these, but they are not in the
> current draft.


Sorry, but I don't think I received it.  Digging through my emails
(including the deleted folder) doesn't show it.  Please re-xmit.


> I would appreciate it if you removed (in the References section) the
> link to "whittle-ivip-db-fast-push", which is now obsolete.  Please
> also remove the link to "Ivip Summary".  I haven't been able to
> maintain this properly as a separate document and it is now just a
> link to Ivip-arch, which is a good introduction to Ivip, and to
> my suggested Recommendation text.


Done.  Please see the next rev., whenever that issues.

 
> Below my signature is some rfc2xml stuff for two new IDs, most
> importantly draft-whittle-ivip-drtm.  If you can make the mention of
> draft-whittle-ivip-drtm in the "rebuttal" link to the reference, that
> would be great.


I'm happy to add the references, but if you want to change the text, please
send explicit changes or new text.

Thanks,
Tony