Re: [DNSOP] Call for Adoption: draft-arends-private-use-tld

[Paul Wouters <[e-mail]>]

On Thu, 18 Jun 2020, Philip Homburg wrote:

>> basically all the domains you list here could have used one of
>> their own domains (eg local.telus.com instead of .telus, etc)
>
> I wonder how that would interact with EU privacy regulations. In the common
> case of an ISP providing the customer with a CPE, the ISP is resposible for
> anything that goes wrong.
>
> We can be sure that there will be plenty of queries that leak out. How does
> an ISP deal with a report that the ISP provided device leads to traffic
> going to the manufacturer of said device?
>
> The obvious next problem is where the manufacturer registers a domain name for
> a product line and then forgets to renew the domain when the product line
> is no longer sold.

But that problem is independent of the domain names used. If the CPE
sends queries to the ISP, the deed has already been done, regardless of
what the ISP does with the query (send it to the root, to telus.com or
drops it)

Paul