Re: [apps-review] Early Cursory Reviews

[Alexey Melnikov <[e-mail]>]

Alexey Melnikov wrote:

> Pete Resnick wrote: 

 [...]

>> said exactly the same thing. Followup question:
>
>> Even if you were assigned one per month, what would be the amount of 
>> time you would want from "pickup out of the queue" until "completion 
>> of review"? What I worry about is the same thing SM is trying to 
>> address with the initial proposed changes: I don't want to wait for a 
>> month to find out that someone is *not* going to be able to complete 
>> a review
>
I think the same 1-2-3 days ACK period should apply to these (as 
discussed in another thread).

>> and then we have to restart the month timer in the queue, especially 
>> for what I'm hoping is an early cursory review. Is one week enough 
>> time to complete a review of this sort, even if you are only asked to 
>> do one per month?
>
> 2 weeks should be enough. Most of IESG doing similar reviews within 1 
> week, but I appreciate that people without proper "IESG training" 
> might need more time.