Re: [DNSOP] I-D Action: draft-vixie-dns-rpz-04.txt

["Allan Liska" <[e-mail]>]

On 12/20/2016 at 12:31 AM, "ac"  wrote:
> If you wish to consider a physical analog, there may be a general
> principle that one should not interfere with postal mail, but this
is
> challeged by the existence of the unabomber or the anthrax attacks.
> 
In your example, you still require a court order, you do not have
standing to make a decision to intervene yourself.

in DNS, it is much more subtle, it is about honesty, morality and
ethics.

Andre

Your nonsense is starting to get annoying.  The whole reason that RPZ
exists is because there are a whole bunch of dishonest, unethical and
immoral people out there registering bad domains and attacking my
users. Tools like RPZ help me defend organizations against these
people, and frankly I don't care if I violate the rights of the
jackhole who registered bank0fammmerica.com to attempt to defraud my
users.  
RPZ is a necessary tool, and it makes a lot of security sense, and I
would much rather have a standardized and well document version of it
so everyone understands it. Go talk to the bad guys about honesty,
morality and ethics and let us know how that goes.  
allan