Re: [v6ops] New Version Notification for draft-hilliard-v6ops-host-addr-update-00.txt - Privacy Properties

[Nick Hilliard <[e-mail]>]

Tim Chown wrote:
> For campus network wifi, you get accountability through eduroam.

s/campus network/eduroam campus network/

There are lots of different types of campus, and campus type networks.

> Many hotspots have zero authentication.

Sadly, there is an increasing number of situations which refuse hotspot
connectivity without authentication, depending on a variety of situations.

>> Note that in cases like hotspots and campus wifi, you would be
>> well advised not to have any expectations of privacy to start with,
>> so in the general case, it would be questionable as to whether
>> these networks would be bcp204 compliant to start with.  This isn't
>> a blanket statement or a position of intent, btw - just an
>> observation that if you use someone else's network resources, you
>> are subject to their policies. </ymmv>
> 
> Yeah things like GDPR would come into play. But let’s not go down
> this rathole; the point is that different scenarios will have
> different expectations and requirements.

indeed, and the ietf needs to acknowledge this explicitly.

Nick